I like this idea a lot! sounds good and fairI have an idea.. Split matchmaking to 2 groups.
Fast Queue - Slow Queue (you can change the name)
- Fast Queue
* All maps are playable. (only bans. No prefered map)
* Dodging penalty is much higher. If you dodged a game you cannot queue in fast queue for... Don't know 1 hour? 2 hours? a day?? Practically you don't want to dodge a game if you want to stay at fast queue.
* You get matched with Fast and Slow queue players (If slow queue player preffered a lesser picked map)
- Slow Queue
* You choose 1 map and 1 alternative. If you pick Arabia prefered and Arena alternative you will guaranteed to play one of them.
* You get matched with other Slow Queue players (If you cannot get preffered map with fast queue players)
* Dodge penalty is similar like now.
If you just want to play... Go fast queue. Maps will be diverse, dodging has harsh penalties
If you want to play a specific game... Go slow queue. You will guaranteed to play that.